The following is from the Oct. 4, 2005, edition of
The New York Times.
Maya Monument May Connect
Little-Known Ruins With Mystery Site
By JOHN NOBLE WILFORD
Forty years ago, the antiquities market in Europe and the United
States was flooded with looted artifacts from the Petén rain forest of
Guatemala. Their artistic style and inscriptions suggested to scholars
that the monumental stones came from an abandoned seventh-century Maya
city at some unidentified remote place, which became known as Site Q.
Now, archaeologists think the mystery has been solved in the
little-known ruins of a place called La Corona. Last week they
reported finding a well-preserved stone monument in two sections
carved with more than 140 hieroglyphs that bear dates and tell stories
of two kings mentioned prominently in the Site Q texts.
The discovery was made in April by Marcello A. Canuto, a Yale
archaeologist who was exploring La Corona. The site is inside the
Laguna del Tigre National Park in northwestern Guatemala, less than 20
miles from the temple ruins of Waka, called El Perú today by local
people.
An analysis of the inscriptions was conducted by Stanley Guenter, a
graduate student and specialist in Mayan writing at Southern Methodist
University in Dallas. He noted the similarities between the style,
chronology and texts of the La Corona monument and those of the looted
material.
"This discovery concludes one of the longest and widest hunts for a
Maya city in the history of the discipline," Dr. Canuto said in an
announcement of a recent lecture at Yale in which he described the
findings.
Dr. David Freidel, a Maya archaeologist at S.M.U. who is a leader of
the nearby Waka excavations, supported the interpretation in an
interview. "This is substantial evidence that this is Site Q," he
said, adding with admiration, "Marcello was touched by the gods."
The discovery was not entirely surprising. In 1997, Ian Graham, an
expert in Mayan hieroglyphs at Harvard, and a colleague, David Stuart,
visited La Corona and came upon stones that made them suspect this was
the long-sought Site Q.
Dr. Graham said in an interview that Dr. Stuart had read one of the
inscriptions, which mentioned the name of a king who also figured in
Site Q texts, and "was pretty much certain" that La Corona was the
source of the looted material. An analysis of the stones suggested
that they came from the same quarry as the Site Q artifacts.
Dr. Graham, who was not involved in the new research, called it an
exciting discovery and "gratifying confirmation" of their earlier
findings, though he conceded that at the time he had some reservations
because of the site's modest size. Its crumbling ruins cover about
two-thirds of a mile square.
Dr. Stuart, now an archaeology professor at the University of Texas,
noted that at an international conference in 2001 he presented
evidence that he said already established the Site Q-La Corona
connection.
Dr. Canuto cautioned that further research might prove that Site Q -
shorthand for the Spanish "qué," meaning "which?" - was not a single
place. Perhaps the looted material will be traced to several sources
with related histories and traditions.
Archaeologists deplore the practice of plundering ancient ruins,
particularly widespread in poorly policed jungles, because they cannot
tell exactly where looted artifacts came from, the all-important
context.
Even so, Dr. Canuto said the newfound limestone monument was the same
type of fine-grained stone used in the looted artwork. This, he said,
"goes a long way to allowing us to demonstrate that many, if not most,
Site Q monuments were looted from La Corona."
Archaeologists said that more intensive excavations there were likely
to uncover other information to establish this as Site Q. A prize
would be to find evidence that the two kings mentioned in the
inscriptions, Chak Naahb' Kaan and his son, K'inich Yook, actually
lived and ruled in this city in the last half of the seventh century.
Mr. Guenter said the panel's hieroglyphs gave a date, the equivalent
of Oct. 25, 677, for the dedication of a shrine temple in which the
monument was found. The temple was dedicated to a god named K'uhul
Winik Ub'.
K'inich Yook, one of the most important kings of his dynasty, was
responsible for the temple. A journey he made to the powerful kingdom
of Calakmul, in present-day Mexico, is described in the text, with an
illustration showing the visiting king performing a ceremony at
Calakmul.
The text also refers to a similar temple dedication carried out by his
father, the previous king, in 658. Scholars said these dates filled
gaps in their knowledge of Maya politics in this jungle region.
Dr. Canuto, Mr. Guenter and other researchers from Southern Methodist
spent a week exploring La Corona supported in part by the National
Geographic Society, the El Perú-Waka Archaeological Project and the
Wildlife Conservation Society. They made their discovery on the last
full day.
While the others were mapping the ruins, Dr. Canuto said, "I looked
into a trench where looters had obviously dug through to the interior"
of a temple. They had stripped the open trench bare, its former
contents presumably becoming some of the goods of illicit trade.
But stepping into the temple interior, the archaeologist came upon the
two stones of the monument, which measured about 40 by 14 inches. He
saw immediately that lines and marks were etched into the gray
limestone. He called for Mr. Guenter to take a look.
The two archaeologists cleaned the surface, exposing a single, long
hieroglyphic text on one stone and a brief text accompanying the
etched illustration on the other. It was not long before they felt
sure of the connection with Site Q.
"The panel exactly mirrors the style, size, subject matter and
historical chronology of the Site Q texts," Dr. Canuto said.
On their last morning, the team excavated and removed the inscribed
stones and sent them to a laboratory in Guatemala City for safekeeping
and more study. Another expedition is planned for a return to La
Corona and a closer examination of other ruins from a time its kings
left words in stone to mark their passage through the classic period
of the Maya civilization.
# # #